When Joe was taken to the hospital, Tillie admitted to having put "white powder" on his food. He would eventually recover, but it turned out that Tillie had had at least three other husbands who had died mysteriously - not to mention that friends and relatives seemed to be in the habit of dying after eating at her house! When her second husband's body was dug up, it was found to contain enough arsenic to kill four men. More was found in the body of her third husband, and more still in the body of the first!
In the brief media storm that followed, several of Tillie's friends and cousins were also arrested on suspicion of poisoning their husbands, and the papers began to refer to Tillie as "high priestess of the bluebeard clique." It seemed that she had killed as many as 20 people - even a neighbor's dog, about whose barking she had complained, was found dead of arsenic poisoning.
The trial was quite a circus - three gravediggers and a "lady undertaker" reportedly kept the audience in stitches - the judge frequently had to remind the giggling onlookers that the court was not a theatre. More and more, her casual demeanor about her husband, who was paralyzed in the hospital at the time, amazed the press. One nurse testified that Tillie had said that "if (Joe) gives you any trouble, hit him over the head with a two by four!"
The jury convicted her of the murder of her third husband and sentenced her to life in prison (where she died 13 years later) - how many others she and her cousin, Nellie Koulik (who was also convicted, but was released a year later when the conviction was overturned) may have killed may never be known, but police at the time suspected around 20.
Despite such a high count and her tendency to be goofy (even in jail, her idea of a good joke was to trick Nellie into thinking she was going to be hanged), she's mostly forgotten today (though some recent - mostly bad - TV segments have revived her somewhat). Those few articles that talk about her tend to stress the idea that she was a supposed "psychic" or fortune teller who went around predicting deaths with astonishing accuracy, but, other than telling her poisoned husband that he would die and planning for the funeral, there was no mention of that sort of thing in the Tribune at the time. The "psychic" angle was probably made up later by pulp writers, though it's easy to see where they got the idea. She certainly did "predict" the deaths of the men she murdered after they got sick!
|A polish woman born (Otillie Gbrurek) who moved to America with her family at the age of one, Tillie Grubrek lived in the area known as "Little Poland." Her last apartment, at 924 N Winchester (near Damen and Augusta) (left) still stands. On the corner is an old building with "Polonia Dairy Co" carved into the stone. Tillie would recognize much more of her neighborhood than most other historical Chicago killers would today.|
What I'd REALLY like to know is what happened to the coffin that Tillie bought for $30 and stored in the basement (with the landlady's permission!).